visitors, exhibition, see, museum, art, gallery, exhibition, museum, museum, museum, museum, museum, gallery, gallery, gallery. How to Test an Arts Organisation's Claims About Money, Audiences and Access
Photo by Peggy_Marco on Pixabay

Guides

How to Test an Arts Organisation's Claims About Money, Audiences and Access

A reporter's method for checking an arts body's finances and audience figures against its public filings: Form 990, UK charity accounts, funder award lists and attendance definitions.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Field Desk.

What to take away

  • Match three things before you read a numberthe legal entity, the return type and the fiscal period. The Metropolitan Museum of Art's year runs 1 July to 30 June, not January to December.
  • Total revenue is not operating cash. In the Met's Form 990 for the year to 30 June 2023, about 50 percent of the US$761.5 million revenue was contributions and about 48 percent was investment income.
  • One filing can hold several audience counts. The same Met return reports ticketed visitors, event attendees, researcher visits and an estimated livestream audience, and they are not additive.
  • A grant on a funder's award list is an award. The recipient's filing shows what it recognised, and the two rarely line up by date or amount.
  • A published access statement is a claim. Test each feature separately and say whether you observed it, were told it, or read it.

Match entity, return and period first

Start with the legal name, not the brand. Then confirm which return you are looking at. The IRS publishes e-filed Form 990 series returns as XML, with an index file that lists the filer's EIN, tax period, return type and an object ID, on its Form 990 series downloads page. The index for 2024 lists two returns for the Metropolitan Museum of Art's tax period ending June 2023: a Form 990 and a Form 990-T. The 990-T reports unrelated business income. They are different documents, and only one answers a question about the museum's overall finances.

Know which form a filer should use. The IRS instructions for Form 990-EZ say it is for organisations with gross receipts under $200,000 and total assets under $500,000 at year end. Organisations at or above either figure generally file the full Form 990. Organisations that normally have gross receipts of $50,000 or less generally file the short Form 990-N. A small company or collective may therefore show you much less detail than a large museum.

Check the deadline too. The IRS says the return is due on the 15th day of the fifth month after the end of the accounting period, so a 30 June year end gives 15 November, with an automatic six-month extension available through Form 8868. Late or extended filings explain why the newest return is often a year behind the press release.

Worked example: one Form 990, read line by line

The Met's Form 990 for the period 1 July 2022 to 30 June 2023 was signed on 13 February 2024. The numbers below come from the filing's IRS XML data, not from the museum's marketing.

Amount (US$)

  • Total revenue761,527,826
  • Contributions and grants383,849,407
  • Investment income366,359,726
  • Program service revenue7,531,830
  • Other revenue3,786,863
  • Total expenses420,244,064
  • Revenue less expenses341,283,762
  • Total assets at year end5,614,873,152
  • Total liabilities at year end617,114,704

Read what this does and does not say:

  • Revenue less expenses is US$341.3 million. That is not a surplus the museum can spend. Contributions include gifts that may be restricted, and a large part of income was investment income. The filing's own balance sheet and Schedule D (endowments) are where restrictions are described.
  • Government grants are US$13,768,863 in the contributions section. That figure covers all governments and agencies. It does not tell you which programs paid.
  • The 990 shows revenue "recognised" in a period. It does not show cash received.

Audited statements add another layer. They follow US GAAP for not-for-profits (FASB Accounting Standards Codification Topic 958) and include an auditor's opinion. An audit is not a 990, and a 990 is not an audit. Cite the one you read. Ask the institution to reconcile any differences before you call them contradictions.

Define the audience unit

Now look at audience numbers in the same filing. The supplemental explanations (Schedule O) give several, mostly for fiscal 2023:

  • 3.9 million ticketed visitors, including 0.2 million at The Met Cloisters. The same text gives over 5.3 million ticketed visitors for fiscal 2019, 1.2 million for fiscal 2021 and 2.9 million for fiscal 2022.
  • 397,078 visitors who attended 17,467 on-site events, plus 600,464 people engaged virtually in hybrid events.
  • 13,234 visits by outside researchers to the Watson Library, plus 2,481 new outside researchers. Visits and people are different units.
  • An "estimated attendance" of more than 220,700 for one livestreamed event.

None of these should be added together or compared with a press-office headline without the definition. Ticketed visitors, event attendees and people reached online are three audiences. The filing also gives shares by origin, such as local visitors at 44 percent of attendance, but a share is only as good as the base it is a share of.

A rounded figure also limits arithmetic. Divide the year's US$420.2 million of expenses by 3.9 million ticketed visitors and you get roughly US$108. But 3.9 million is rounded, so the true result could be a dollar or two either side. More importantly, expenses cover curatorial work, acquisitions, education and digital media, not only the visit. A "cost per visitor" built this way would be a misleading headline. Editorial suggestion: use such a ratio only to ask the institution a question, never as a finding.

Trace a named grant to the funder's list

A claim that "the NEA funded this" needs two documents. The funder's award list shows the recommended grant, and the recipient's filing shows what it recorded.

The National Endowment for the Arts publishes grant lists by fiscal year and a recent grants search. The State/City/Town list released with its second-round FY 2023 announcement (the PDF's own header still says "first round of NEA recommended grants", and it says it is current as of 16 May 2023) gives each grantee's name, amount, city, discipline and purpose. One entry reads: Maysles Institute, Inc. (aka Maysles Documentary Center), US$35,000, New York, NY, Grants for Arts Projects, Media Arts, to support free film education programs. The same list shows Metropolitan Opera Guild, Inc. at US$55,000 under Grants for Arts Projects - Arts Education for an opera education residency program.

Three checks follow:

  1. Name match. Searching that May 2023 list for the Metropolitan Museum of Art returns no entry, while two other "Metropolitan" organisations appear (Metropolitan Arts Council of Greater Kansas City and Metropolitan Opera Guild). The Met does appear in the NEA's earlier FY 2023 first-round list, current as of 3 January 2023, at US$40,000 under Grants for Arts Projects - Museums. Searching one list is not searching the funder's records, and a name match alone proves nothing.
  2. Period match. The NEA's fiscal year follows the federal year (1 October to 30 September). A museum with a July to June year will record the same grant in a different fiscal year, or across two.
  3. Category match. The Met's US$13.8 million of government grants cannot be split into federal, state and city sources from the Form 990 line alone. Ask for the award letters.

Lists are updated and recommended grants can change. The NEA's own list tells readers to use the Recent Grant Search for current information.

UK filings and access claims

For a UK body, the equivalent public record is the charity register, not a tax return. The Charity Commission says charities in England and Wales must send an annual return within 10 months of the financial year end. Charitable companies and unincorporated charities with income over £25,000 must also provide the trustees' annual report and accounts, and charitable incorporated organisations provide them whatever their income. The commission says accounting thresholds change for financial years ending on or after 30 September 2026. In Scotland, OSCR gives charities 9 months, and publishes the reports and accounts of charities with income of £25,000 or more. For how to read those accounts, see the UK charity fact-check guide. For the funding bodies behind the numbers, see UK arts councils explained.

On access, test the feature, not the policy. In the US, the Department of Justice says Title III of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act covers businesses, including nonprofits, that serve the public, and that new construction and alterations must be accessible. Compliance cannot be assessed from a web page. Check entrances, lifts, seating, toilets, captioning and audio description one by one. Write down whether each was observed, tested, reported by users or confirmed by staff.

When a figure changes after publication, say whether the first one was wrong, preliminary, defined differently or from another period. Fix it in the headline, chart and social copy as well as the text. For smaller or informal organisations, the same questions apply in the festival and community arts guide.

Sources

More in Guides

Latest from Amelia B. Hayes